By Neil C. Manson

It is a excellent critique of the reason for and current perform of utilizing trained consent in study and scientific perform. to a point, this booklet is a sequel to O'Neill's past paintings on bioethics. In her Autonomy and belief in Bioethics, O'Neill offered a really potent critique of the reliance at the proposal of autonomy and the character of the concept that of autonomy utilized in scientific and study ethics. O'Neill argued good that the reliance at the precept of autonomy used to be poorly formulated and contributed to erosion of belief. within the current e-book, O'Neill and Manson offer an efficient critique of the normal proficient consent procedure and current a conceptual substitute. Manson and O'Neill argue that the current trained consent doctrine shows a lost emphasis on autonomy, is essentially tough, and ends up in overlook of ethically useful elements of verbal exchange among physicians/researchers and patients/participants. They recommend that the current version is predicated on a "container" method of offering info that has significant defects. Manson and O'Neill current a version of trained consent according to a "waiver" of particular responsibilities and rights and an "agency" version of the consent procedure which attempts to emphasize the total spectrum of necessities for powerful communique. This version is prolonged to a couple similar matters like information privateness and genetic concerns in a rigorous means that produces ideas at variance with current perform. Manson's and O'Neill's critique is punctiliously built and convincing. the foremost predicament of this e-book is that it truly is theoretically powerful however the authors' feedback for concrete alterations are rather modest. Regardless, the arguments built during this ebook are even more rigorous and good based than these present in the good majority of the bioethics literature.

Show description

Read or Download Rethinking Informed Consent in Bioethics PDF

Best medical ethics books

Routledge Handbook of Medical Law and Ethics

This e-book explores the scope, program and position of clinical legislations, regulatory norms and ethics, and addresses key demanding situations brought through modern advances in biomedical examine and healthcare. whereas conscious of nationwide advancements, the guide helps an international standpoint in its method of clinical legislation.

GenEthics: Technological Intervention in Human Reproduction as a Philosophical Problem

This publication was once first released in 1994. Ever in view that Plato, human replica has been a subject matter for philosophical hypothesis. The final 20 years aren't any exception. rather the opposite: contemporary technological revolutions in the box of human copy has provoked between philosophers mirrored image and ongoing controversies.

The Nature of the Doctor-Patient Relationship: Health Care Principles through the phenomenology of relationships with patients

This booklet serves to unite biomedical ideas, which were criticized as a version for fixing ethical dilemmas via placing them and figuring out them in the course of the standpoint of the phenomenon of health and wellbeing care courting. hence, it attributes a potential unification of virtue-based and principle-based techniques.

The Different Faces of Autonomy: Patient Autonomy in Ethical Theory and Hospital Practice

Sufferer autonomy is a miles mentioned and debated topic in clinical ethics, in addition to in healthcare perform, clinical legislation, and healthcare coverage. This ebook offers a close and nuanced research of either the idea that of autonomy and the main of admire for autonomy, in an available sort. the original characteristic of this booklet is that it combines empirical study into medical institution perform with thorough philosophical analyses.

Additional info for Rethinking Informed Consent in Bioethics

Sample text

Side of a river? or some other ‘bank’ (a blood bank? brain bank? )? Why is Sue saying this at all? Tom’s 9 Extensional contexts are ones where the truth of a claim does not depend upon how the objects it is about are described or referred to. Extensional contexts are typically contrasted with referentially opaque contexts, already mentioned in Chapter 1. If we assume that all information is extensional we will ignore or downplay the essential links between information and propositional attitudes like belief and intention.

29 We could shut our eyes to these problems and to the very widespread failure to achieve standards of 29 See Dawson, ‘What Should We Do About It’, which argues that we face a choice between (i) stopping research because the conditions for consent cannot be met; (ii) continuing with research, but keeping quiet about the fact that we know that the ethical standards have not been met; or (iii) – in our view the most promising option – reviewing and revising informed consent procedures. Consent: Nuremberg, Helsinki and beyond 25 consent and consenting that meet the prescribed standards.

The regulation of clinical medicine and of medical research is a vast topic, which has attracted a correspondingly large critical literature. 26 In this book we shall consider only a limited range of regulatory requirements for informed consent to certain types of non-invasive action. Even within this circumscribed area there is more complexity, more legislation and more regulation than we shall be able to discuss in any detail, and we shall focus specifically on some of the implications of informed consent requirements for further uses of information and tissues already legitimately held.

Download PDF sample

Rated 5.00 of 5 – based on 11 votes